Handling Criticism: A growing pain

From August 1 2024 to April 5 2026, I served as Pastoral Associate at a PCUSA church in my local area. It was a VERY interesting experience, one that I will be sharing about as I am inclined to. maybe there is a series here. Who knows maybe titled the Journey of a PASToral ASSociate who knows. Anyway, here's a paper that I wrote for class (I am in seminary finishing up my masters)...

 I have of late, begun to think and speak of my time in my current position as something akin to being on death row. It is accurate in the sense that I know that, save a stay of execution (a delay in the hiring of a called pastor) my scheduled date of departure is April 5, 2026. It is both saddening and liberating at once. With a swiftly approaching end date in sight, I have clarity about what matters most.

There is one sister in the congregation who has been consistently critical of me. While she has never said anything negative to me face to face, what I have heard ‘through the grapevine’ is that she is definitely not a fan. Interestingly it is never about the content of my sermons, it is about me as a person.

I have been tempted to confront her directly, but I do not, because:

1) doing this would betray the trust of those who have confided in me, and 

2) I am not sure that confronting her would serve anything other than my pride, and not peace in the church. 

That said, I have considered her pronouncements, the most oft-repeated is that I am a ‘people pleaser.’ That was definitely true of my younger, pre-ministry years. But now?

I am affable and pleasant, yes; I do try to be amenable without being evasive. But something about her words did hurt me, and made me examine myself and my motives. I do not preach to be liked, I do not lead worship for people to tell me how nice my voice is, I had enough of that playing in bands and touring for years, and yet, it hurt… I had to ask myself why?

In considering this situation, and deciding to write about it, I have been confronted by Jesus words in Matthew 5: 43 “You have heard that it was said, Love your neighbor, and hate your enemy. 44 But I tell you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you…”[1]

McKnight’s words: “So Jesus confronts us with himself, sets before us the radical choice between obedience and disobedience, and calls us to an unconditional commitment of mind, will and life to his teaching”[2] have also been important.

In considering both, I found my answer: beneath my maturity lay remnants of vanity, a desire to be well-regarded, a lingering attachment to approval. Like Lazarus, I had been raised, but some graveclothes still clung. Her criticism revealed not simply her disposition, but my unfinished sanctification.

And I stand convicted. I have not been praying for my sister, or the situation. Worse yet, I have at times thought of her less than kindly, while imagining myself wronged. Jesus does not offer emotional permission for resentment; He commands active love expressed through prayer. It has caused me to repent. I was considering the mote in her eye, while ignoring the beam in my own.

 

As I tell my congregation: ‘If you can’t say Amen, say Ouch’

Well OUCH! And Glory to God for it…

 



[1] Christian Standard Bible (Nashville, TN: Holman Bible Publishers, 2020), Mt 5:43–44.

[2] Scot McKnight, Sermon on the Mount, ed. Tremper Longman III and Scot McKnight, The Story of God Bible Commentary (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 2013), 21.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

You Must be FORMED:

The Clubdate Singer Speaks! Chapter 8: The Conflict

"Pope and Change"